Know When to Fold Em' - Libby Glass Versus China Knockoffs

A wave of discounting at the national level iswe decided to sell down our inventory over time
forcing purchasing departments to cut costs onand give the benefit of deeper discounts to our
basic glass packaging. As consumers cut back onexisting - and loyal - customers.
affordable luxuries, coffee roasters like StarbucksEvery day we encounter bidding opportunities for
are even looking at entry level products to sell tolarge quantities of glass containers. Since we have
consumers such as "instant" coffee and teabecome a national distributor for Libby Glass,
mixes. Box store discounters are weathering thewe've found that companies that buy into the
economic crisis by continuing a pattern of markconcept of American made glass jars are willing
downs for unemployed and low income folks. Asto pay a premium for the quality, integrity and
such, most glass fillers are now offering someconsistency of Libby Glass. But what exactly is a
type of low priced glass container. To do this,premium? 25%, 50%, 100%? What more are
they have sought the help of lower cost Chinesethey really willing to pay?
manufacturers.When we come up against competitors, we hear
The funny thing about sourcing in China is that ifthe same mantra every time: "we want the Libby
you lack the resources, skills, relationships andGlass, but we need the jars for nothing." Big
wherewithal to prevent quality problems andcandle makers and gourmet packers are dropping
delays in delivery, buying in the Mainland is a fool'stheir pricing and using cost advantages to capture
game. Every buyer seems to have unrealistica larger share of the market at the expense of
expectations on pricing, not least minimum orders.smaller producers. To combat this and help our
That forces even the savviest and well positionedclients compete, we drop our pricing and give
importer to stock up on glass containerthem insider's knowledge on the trends in shapes
inventories that are unsalable. As the market falls,and styles that will force them to buy American if
the idea of moving more glass jars is problematicthe buyer's focus is differentiation.
- to whom and how quickly?Although we lose some projects by not
We recently tried to liquidate a large percentageoutsourcing glass jars overseas, we find that
of our remaining China inventory. No matter howeventually we'll win business, at our price, when
low our pricing, we couldn't get any retailers tothe Chinese fail. The beauty of working in China
commit! Even the largest distributors of closeoutfor the last 15 years is that we know that we'll
inventories such as Big Lots and Christmas Treewin more than 50% of the business, if not initially,
Shops are overloaded with closeouts that theythen immediately when their overseas supply
couldn't sell. I found that getting anyone tochain defaults. It usually takes at least a year for
purchase in bulk is extremely difficult; offer pricescustomers to drop their sourcing programs. When
are so low that recapturing 25 or 30% of yourthey do, we step in and fill their orders - and
cost would be considered a good deal. As a result,name our price.